BOOK A CALL

How Is Ambidexterity Initiated? The Emergent Charter Definition Process

Summary for agile leaders

Investigation of the alliances with four suppliers shows how ambidexterity between firms may emerge beyond the original contract. This effect is shaped by managers, bottom-up and horizontally-out. Two alliances were exploitative (outsourcing) and two explorative (designing new products). One of each emerged into an ambidextrous alliance, whilst the other two were constrained by top management.

Reviewed: 02 Jan 2023 by Russ Lewis
Request full analysis of this paper 
Authors: 
Alexander Zimmermann, Sebastian Raisch, Julian Birkinshaw
Publication date: 
2015
DOI: 
10.1287/orsc.2015.0971

My classifications

Abstract

Ambidexterity research has presented a range of structural and contextual approaches for implementing a dual orientation across organizations. Much less is known about the preceding process through which organizations decide to adopt an ambidextrous orientation. In this paper we focus on this first step—the charter definition process through which the activities and responsibilities of an organizational unit are agreed. Most prior studies implicitly assume that senior executives at some point identify the need to become ambidextrous and subsequently design supportive structures and contexts to implement their choice. Based on an inductive multilevel case study of four alliances, we show how this mandated (or top-down) charter definition process can be complemented with an alternative emergent (or bottom-up) charter definition process in which frontline managers take the initiative to adopt an ambidextrous orientation in their part of the organization. This emergent process is important because it enables frontline managers to respond in a timely manner to changing requirements of which senior executives are still unaware. We use the findings from our case study to develop potentially generalizable observations on the level of initiation, the tensions, the management approaches to deal with the tensions, and the outcomes that characterize this emergent charter definition process. We then put forward a multilevel process framework of how organizations initiate an ambidextrous orientation, and we discuss theoretical implications for the general ambidexterity literature, the nascent dynamic view on ambidexterity, and the broader research on how charters in organizations evolve.

Cite as (Harvard referencing)

Zimmermann, A., Raisch, S., Birkinshaw, J., 2015. How Is Ambidexterity Initiated? The Emergent Charter Definition Process. Organization Science 26, 1119–1139
October 6, 2021
What does focussing on culture mean to XYZ Consulting?

We have some mid-tier consultants in at the moment who are "focussing on culture." Since we don't separate culture from delivering value to customers, I asked what that meant in practice. Apparently: "A generic scheme of manoeuvre could involve a diagnostic that looks at things like empowerment, psychological safety, collaboration, purpose, customer centricity… then based […]

Read More
July 7, 2016
Shu Ha Ri: a Chef Metaphor for Agile Learning

The Shu Ha Ri Agile learning metaphor Agile learning is crucial to agile transformation. And, nobody tells the Shu Ha Ri learning metaphor better than Alistair Cockburn as I discovered listening to his Sushi-slicing version whilst in France last year. As I was in France, I was inspired to write a Chef version of Shu […]

Read More
September 23, 2014
Agile Estimation Cards and the Art of Kitchen Renovation

Construction runs to a well-established plan Simon is a project manager who is having some building work done at home - an extension with a new kitchen. We were discussing Agile project management and specifically Estimation Cards. He pointed-out that his "development team" consisted of builders, electricians, plumbers and kitchen fitters, who all worked to […]

Read More
1 2 3 15
Copyright Russ Lewis 1994-2025
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram